Monday, December 21, 2009
Mini Truckin Baby Names
Best Boat Seat Springfield
Thursday, December 3, 2009
Lightheaded After First Cigarette
Judgement Supreme Court, Civil Chamber I, section 1, Date: January 15, 2008
In the town of Madrid, to January 15 of two thousand eight.
Viewed by the First Chamber Supreme Court, composed of Their Excellencies. Mr. Justices indicated in the margin, the appeals brought by Andalusian Cooperative Society "UNION", represented by the Solicitor of the Courts D. Sunday Lake Duck and ALVIC, SA, represented by Attorney D. Courts Carmelo Gomez Olmos, against the Judgement, on April 14, 2000, by Section II of the Provincial Court of Jaen, in the roll of appeal No 423/98 which decided the appeal filed on his day against the Judgement he had acted, the Court of First Instance Number Two, of Alcala La Real.
BACKGROUND FACT
FIRST. Before the District Court Number Two of Alcala The Reall, filed an action for ordinary proceedings are minor, D ª. Jane, against the entity Sociedad Cooperativa Andaluza "UNION", against the entity Andalusian Cooperative Society "St. Elias" against D. Jaime, and against the company ALVIC, SA The Claim Appeals reads as follows: ".... is issued at the time sentence under which order the entities and individual defendants jointly and severally, to pay the plaintiff , as compensation for the parents of the victim Don Gabino, the amount of FIFTEEN MILLION THREE HUNDRED TWENTY FOUR THOUSAND PESETAS (15,325,400 pts.) Plus legal interest, as well as the payment of legal costs.
Declared admissible demand were placed the defendants, alleging a representation of the Sociedad Cooperativa Andaluza "LA UNION "as facts and legal arguments that apply to the case considered, finally asking:" ... Judgement handed down at the time in which, either by estimating the objections raised by this part at the beginning of this writing, or by the background, completely dismiss the suit and acquit me of all claims represented, all explicitly condemning the plaintiff to pay all incurred in the litigation. "
Representing the Andalusian Cooperative Society" St. Elias ", argued the facts and legal arguments it considered applicable to the case and ended up pleading," ... sentencing to dismiss the demand for my Cooperativa San Elias represented either by the alleged lack of standing to be sued, or if the exceptions in the background ".
Jaime representation, relied on the facts and legal law it deemed applicable to the case and ended up pleading, "... Judgement handed down in the day on which either estimating the proposed exceptions or entering the substance of the matter, entirely dismiss the demand with the express imposition of costs against the plaintiff. "
The representation of the business entity" ALVIC, SA ", argued the facts and legal arguments that estimated applicable to the case and ended up pleading, "... to be given in his day sentence, which was acquitted of the application to my client, with imposition of costs against the plaintiff."
the Answered demand and given the appropriate moves, it was agreed to invite the parties to the Hearing under the Act, which was held at the date and time set and having Request to receive the suit to the test, which proposal was carried by the parties, relevant and was declared with the result that work on cars.
By resolution of May 14, 1998, it was agreed to refer the case to the prosecution, to report, have noted a possible lack of jurisdiction. The prosecution, evacuated the transfer conferred by report dated May 22, 1998 in the following sense: "The prosecutor, evacuating the procedure given for the purposes specified in Art. 9.6 of the Judicial Power Organization Act and in relation to jurisdiction in this procedure estimates that the power to resolve claims for compensation for damages arising from liability for breach of job duties by the employer of the accident determinants corresponds to social law, given that the action brought, trained in the art. 1902 Civil Code, as well as other claims arising from normal accident, has its origin in a single causal event, ie an occupational accident suffered by the worker in performance of contract work, what is before individual conflict arising from the contract (05.03.1995 STS). "
The Court of First Instance handed down Judgement dated June 2, 1998, and the following part: "FAULT: That without examining the merits of the lawsuit filed by the Attorney Ms. Jiménez Sánchez, on behalf of Ms. Juana against Sociedad Cooperativa Andaluza "The Union" means Sociedad Cooperativa Andaluza "St. Elias" commercial entity "ALVIC, SA and D. James, I absolve and acquit on the instance to the said defendants for lack of jurisdiction of this Court to hear this litis, notwithstanding that the plaintiff can exercise their right before the social court order. All this with no place to express imposition of costs. "
SECOND. Judgement against that appealed D ª. Juana. Substantiated the appeal, the Second Section of the Audiencia Provincial de Jaén issued a Judgement, dated April 14, 2000, with the next part "Fault: What estimating the appeal lodged against the ruling of the Court of 1st Instance No. . Two of Alcalá la Real, dated June 2 of 1998 the Court of Small Claims Judgement followed in this Court under number 144 of year 1997, we reverse and reverse that decision and instead, rejecting the except for lack of jurisdiction and going to the merits of the case, we should condemn and condemn the defendants UNION SCA, SCA SAN ELIAS, D. Jaime Y ALVIC, SA, to jointly and severally liable to the plaintiff the sum of ten Juana million pesetas, legal interests of that sum from the filing of the claim, without express imposition of the costs in both instances.
THREE. The Andalusian Cooperative Society "LA UNION", represented by the Solicitor of the Courts Mr. Domingo Lake Duck formally appeal against the Judgement of the Audiencia Provincial de Jaén, Section II, based on the following Reason:
First: Based on the number 1 of article 1692 of the Code of Civil Procedure, for excess in the exercise of jurisdiction, not the application of Article 2 a) of the Labour Procedure Act in relation to Article 9.5 of the Organic Law of the Judiciary and article 533.1 of the Civil Procedure Act.
Second: Based on the number 3 of article 1692 of the Civil Procedure Act, for breach of the rules governing the actions and safeguards, including Article 359 of the LEC., Concerning Article 248.3 of the Judicial Power Organization Act, and violation of the principle of effective judicial protection, enshrined in Article 24.1 of the English Constitution.
Third: Based on the number 4 of article 1692 of the Civil Procedure Act, violation of rules of law, for improper implementation of Article 1902 of the Civil Code.
Four: Based on the number 4 of article 1692 of the Civil Procedure Act, misapplication violation of Article 4.1 of the Civil Code.
also representing ALVIC, SA, formally appeal against the Judgement of the Court Provincial de Jaén, based on the following grounds:
First: Based on the number 2 of article 1692 of the Civil Procedure Act by not implementing the Supreme Court jurisprudence.
Second: Based on the number 4 of article 1692 of the Civil Procedure Act, breach of the rules of the legal system, violation of Articles 1902 and 1903 of the CC.
Third: On the basis of Article 1692 of the Civil Procedure Act, misuse or misapplication of the Court established the requirements for the joint liability under Article 1902 of the CC.
FOUR. Supported resources and evacuated the transfer conferred on the matter, the Attorney D. Carmelo Gómez Olmos, on behalf of ALVIC, SA had written, requesting sentencing appreciating the plea of \u200b\u200bjurisdiction to abstain from hearing the merits or, alternatively, entering the substance of the case to be dismissed represented.
FIVE. It was noted as a day to vote and heard the appeal on May 16, two thousand seven, himself suspended and agreed resolution of the same date that the Judgement handed down by the Plenary of the judges of this court, pointing to the vote and the July 18 ruling at ten thirty hours of its morning and is not possible termination of vote and failed, it was noted again for completion on December 19th at ten thirty hours of the morning, which has taken place.
has been Reporter Judge Hon. Mrs D ª. ROCA TRIAS EMBODIMENT
LEGAL
FIRST.
1 The January 10, 1995 D. Gabino, hired by the Cooperative Society "LA UNION" was working in the construction of an industrial property ALVIC, SA, assembling the trusses of the metal structure. As he was proceeding to the final assembly, which were set by three straps interim, there was the collapse of the structure, hitting one of the worker Gabino, who died as a result of the collapse.
2 The mother of the deceased worker, Ms Joan sued the Andalusian cooperatives "UNION", the Sociedad Cooperativa Andaluza "SAN ELIAS, D. Jaime and society ALVIC, SA
3 º The terms of the application are as follows: A cooperative "LA UNION" be sued "as the company for which the injured person was serving, be it through personal charge of the work The obligation to take security measures and responsible for ordering the work so that no puts in risk the integrity of workers employed in the work. Lack of security measures and precautions to eliminate risk in execution of works, which were efficient causes of the accident. "
A D. Jaime Industrial Engineer for its double authorship project execution and the Optional Director's work "because" in his capacity as Technical Director responsible for execution of work imposes a duty to watch over the security measures in the work, especially monitoring and compliance with standards of safety work in particular pose a special risk, as were those who were executed at the time of the accident. "
A cooperative society" St. Elias "because subcontracted work to "the Union" because the contract "does not eliminate the responsibility of the contractor as long as continues to maintain its obligation to monitor such jobs, eliminate the risk in their implementation and, especially, the security measures, being forced to demand (culpa in monitor). "
A ALVIC entity, SA," as the owner and promoter of work, to the extent that this condition bears the same obligation requiring surveillance and security measures of the work, caring expressly special vigilance when it comes to work involving a risk in themselves extraordinary. "
As Fundamentals of law cited in the application of Articles 1902 and 1903 CC and the arts. 24.3 and 42 of Law 31/1995, November 8, Prevention of occupational hazards and especially "as basis of liability," violated the rules regarding Health and Safety at Work, as expressed in the General Ordinance and Safety at Work (9 OM September 1971) and the Labour Ordinance of the Construction Sector (MO August 8, 1970).
4 º The various defendants answered alleging the plea of \u200b\u200bjurisdiction, lack of standing and lack of joinder passive person required as well as affecting the merits.
1 The Court of First Instance and Instruction 2 of Alcalá la Real ruled on June 2, 1998, which upheld the objection of lack of jurisdiction, because "the claim for damages based on infringement by the defendants of the legislation on health and safety at work emanates from the General Order and Safety at Work and Labour Ordinance Construction Sector as appropriate in accordance with the doctrine set out to estimate the objection raised, and therefore dictate acquittal in this instance, subject that the plaintiff may bring an action arising from the accident subject of the litigation before the social court order. " In short states that when you are faced with damage whose production is attributed to an unlawful employment, civil liability must be considered on track and not the civil work.
appeal on that decision, the Provincial Court of Jaen, second section, on April 14, 2000, rejected the plea of \u200b\u200black of jurisdiction. On the substance of the matter said proved the existence of damage, action or omission "made without malice, but contrary to the general mandate to act diligently," which was evident from the reports of the inspection procedure in the present work. Concerning causation, held as follows in relation to each of the defendants:
a) En cuanto a la Sociedad Cooperativa "La Unión", como encargada de la construcción de la estructura metálica y la Sociedad Cooperativa San Elías, contratada para la construcción de la nave, su responsabilidad "viene configurada por la ausencia del más elemental cuidado en orden a la adopción de medidas de seguridad para los trabajadores a su cargo";
b) El director técnico de la obra es también responsable no sólo del aspecto técnico de la construcción "como algo inherente a sus conocimientos, sino también en la adopción de las medidas necesarias, para salvaguardar la integridad de los trabajadores, cuestiones that must be considered in the project, "
c) For the owner of the work, ALVIC society, must be held responsible because" the work started without a license, and although this aspect has an impact administrative, notwithstanding the request of the same requires the completion of a project, which shall contain safety standards to ensure the integrity of the workers and the appropriate construction of the ship. "
In previous deduced the judgment reasoning that "it can be concluded that the liability of damaging event reached by both the promoter and the Technical Director of the work. "Consequently, upheld the appeal and with it the claim and ordered all the defendants jointly.
made against this ruling this appeal Cooperative Society" UNION "and the entity Commercial ALVIC, SA
1 The question of jurisdiction reported on the resources of Cooperative Society "Union" and ALVIC, SA
SECOND. The two actions reported excess in the exercise of jurisdiction by the Recurrent Cooperative Society "The Union" condemns the failure to implement Article 2 a) of the Labour Procedure Act (Royal Decree Law 2 / 1995 of 7 April), under Article 9.5 and Article 533.1 LOPJ LEC and misinterpretation of the order of the Board of Conflicts of April 4, 1994, in relation to the decision of the Board of March 21 1997. ALVIC society, SA believes that it has applied the jurisprudence of this Court on the social responsibility of the jurisdiction where the damage is caused in an accident at work and concurs omission by the employer of the security measures established by law. When matching two reasons, we must rule on its admissibility before entering separately consider each of the resources.
THREE. To solve this problem we must remember before what has been the position of this Court in recent years regarding the competence of civil jurisdiction for claims of liability for accidents.
initially considered that the employer's liability for the accident should have contractual nature, because it was a done outside the contract of employment, applying the argument, common in the jurisprudence of the time, that it was an event that was "outside the orbit of the agreement rigorous" (SSTS January 5, 1982, March 9, 1983, July 5, 1983, 21 October 1988, November 8, 1990 .)
Between 1997-98 and over the previous design, which was dominant in the jurisprudence of the 1 st try to open a line step resolution of these conflicts, which excluded the jurisdiction of the civil jurisdiction when the claim for damages was based on breach of labor standards. For example, the statement of 24 December 1997 reads: "The plea raises the nature of the breach of the regulations on safety and health at work, specifically the liquefied or pressurized gas (MW March 9, 1971, art. 110) , which causes damage to the worker in the development of their work. Under the Judgments of this Court of 19 July 1989 and October 2, 1994 as stated by the Special Chamber Competition Conflict of this Supreme Court, this implies the failure of employment by the offending company, and the reasons given in that room Autos of December 23, 1993, April 4, 1994 and June 10, 1996 and on the Kalends statements we refer to avoid unnecessary repetitions. This entails not only the estimation of the plea, but that this Court has to apply as of right, being of public order, the arts. 9.5 of the Organic Law of Judicial Power and 1 and 2 of the Labour Procedure Act, thereby nullifying all the steps taken in this litigation, and returning the parties to the jurisdiction of social to raise before it, if interested, their claims. "In this sense pronounced sentences of 26 December 1997, February 10, 1998 and March 20, 1998. The latter, after summarizing the two lines of this Chamber resolution of the problem of competition, said, "is to be sustained now that when we realize that diversity solving, about the competition issue, it is necessary to reproduce what the point is solved repeatedly, the Board Conflict Competition (whose decisiveness "ad hoc" is indisputable) on the subject, and thus are significant arguments, the following decisions issued by this Board, the Order of December 23, 1993 in which explained: "... it is appropriate to point out as follows: a) The undisputed fact cars qualification as an occupational accident, which could imply the existence of a conflict arising from the relationships individual's own employment contract. b) Attribution the social order of the court to hear the claims promoted within the social arm of the law in individual and collective disputes, and contentious issues to be promoted among employers and workers as a result of the employment contract, arts. 1 and 2. a) of Royal Decree no. 521/1990 of 27 April on working procedure, the aforementioned allocation in the first sense that it coincides with the one assigned to order expressed in art. 9.5 of Organic Law 6 / 1985 of 1 July, the Judicial Branch. c) The rules on work safety and hygiene is one of the oldest forms of state intervention in the autonomy of the parties to the employment relationship, and represents, in the words of Decree 2065/1974, of 30 May approving the Consolidated Text of the General Law of Social Security, which aim to: eliminate or reduce the risks of individual schools or jobs, and encourage and develop people within the scope of the this Act a positive and constructive approach to the prevention of accidents and diseases arising from their professional activities, art. 26. A) and b). d) A worker in the provision of services shall be entitled to effective protection of safety and hygiene, with the employer required to provide practical training and appropriate in this matter to the workers it employs, or change their jobs work or have to apply a new technique that can cause serious risks to the worker or their partners or others, art. 19.1 and 4 of the Act 8 / 1980 of March 10 of the Statute of Workers, and in this vein, for the art. 4.2. B) d) of the Statute, are labor law: promotion and training in the worker's physical and adequate health and safety policy. ... Many considerations have been drawn to the conclusion that in the present case, however the 'vis attractiva' which characterizes the civil courts and the similarities that offer with tort cases prevented in the arts. 1902 and 1903 of the CC, the competent court to hear it is the corresponding social order ...".
This trend did not, however, with unanimous support of the Board, so that from the Judgement of 13 October 1998, with reference to some earlier, becomes the traditional approach of assuming jurisdiction because the damage occurs outside the orbit of what is strictly agreed in the contract. That ruling states that "what happened was the production of a harmful outcome as a result of an act performed in daily work, which exceeds the specific orbit of the employment contract, and it is understandable that their knowledge for the civil order status and extend the same residual, specified in Article 9.2 of the Organic Law of Judicial Power, especially when the claim is made reference to the personal action is brought for compensation for damages covered in articles 1902 and 1903 of Civil Code, doctrine, moreover, this Court has consistently (For all, STS March 21, 1997). In the same vein were pronouncing the sentences of 24 and 30 November and 18 December 1998, 1 February, 10 April, 13 July and 30 November 1999 and the March 2 May 26, 2000 and this despite the ruling of February 11, 2000 pick up the thesis of the incompetence of the civil jurisdiction in a work accident, saying "The stated reason must be rejected, because despite the name which the actor given in the application (from tort liability), the fact is that the only real action in the process referred to this action, exercising the plaintiff, appellant here, is the contractual liability for breach by company employment contract between the parties, but not observe the rules laid down in Health and Safety at Work (by not providing the worker applicant glasses or shields), and that being so, as indeed it is, both the First Chamber as the Special Court Competition Conflict of this Supreme Court, have proclaimed the doctrine that when the action taken is the contractual liability for breach of contract of employment by the company, knowledge of that action is the exclusive jurisdiction of the Court or the Social Work (Judgments of the First Board of July 19, 1989, October 2, 1994, December 26, 1997 and October 24 1998 and Car of the Special Chamber of Conflicts of Jurisdiction of this Court of December 23, 1993 and April 4, 1994). "Anyway, there was general satisfaction about the criteria used for the resolution of this problem and will reflect the decision of October 8, 2001, which recognized the "degree of disagreement" between the various resolutions of the Board about the competence of civil courts in respect of claims for injury, says that "However , resources must be resolved now considered consistent with the approach taken after those cases and remained until today, so that claims based on the arts. CC 1902 and 1903 must be concluded that the jurisdiction belonged to the same civil jurisdiction and therefore must thrive in the absence of reasonable grounds in the exercise of jurisdiction, "adding that" [C] can not ertainly considered entirely satisfactory solution that meets strict formalist especially the rule invoked by the plaintiff. But such a solution is but a manifestation of a larger problem in that the labor standards alone does not lead to full compensation for the damage even if the surcharge applies to benefits for breach of safety regulations (art. 123, corresponding to art. 93 of TR 1974), this is the fault of the employer premium priced and also whose legal (punitive or restorative) is also the subject of a lively controversy. Hence, being now evident in our legal system to overcome the principle of immunity of the employer and the limits of repair, essential in their day to initially set the coverage of accidents in the Law of 30 January 1900 strict liability as a business risk, be advisable, given the consistency between claims based on civil liability of the employer and Social Security benefits arising from the same factual situation (art. 127.3 of the current TR LGSS and art. 97 -3 of TR effect at the time of the events), maintain, guarantee the principle of full compensation for the damage, the jurisdiction of civil courts to deal with the possible fault of the employer based on the arts. 1902 and 1903 CC.
The criteria used to determine whether or not the jurisdiction of civil courts are clearly expressed in the sentence whose reasoning we have transcribed so that is distinguished, in general, depending As requested in the application. If the claim is solely based on the infringement of labor laws, declaring the jurisdiction of the labor law and the consequent lack of civil (SSTS 6 March May 4 and September 28, 2006), while the 20 July and 4 October 2006 declared the jurisdiction of civil courts for having founded the claim in tort or tort of business defendants. This solution appears to be based on the criteria so far followed by the Board 1 st, to require that the claim is based purely civilian rule inexorably, therefore, excluding labor.
FOUR. This was not, however, the approach of orders made by the Board of the Supreme Court conflicts. Since cars December 23, 1993, April 4, 1994 and June 10, 1996, the Board of conflicts has spoken in favor of the jurisdiction of the court order social to meet claims made by workers affected by occupational accidents. The arguments used to arrive at this conclusion are based on the employer's duties regarding safety of workers are part of the employment relationship, so that his offense creates a contractual liability for breach of contract work, competition that involves the organs of social law, in accordance with the provisions of Article 9 LOPJ (see also the two orders of December 21, 2000). The order of February 28, 2007 outlines the criteria used by the Board of conflicts, repeatedly and consistently since 1993. These criteria, summarized, are: a) the relationship between employer and employee, the responsibility has a strong contract to derive the damage of a contract of employment, b) the obligation of prevention part, regulation, contract, c) the obligation ex lege, must mean that "[the] failure to follow the norms that guarantee safety in the workplace by the employer, constitutes a breach of employment contract, a contract that is the key parameter to determine and define the competition [.. .] "so that when demand compensation for the contract of employment" [q] hat has occurred as a result of the violation of a safety obligation [...]", the social jurisdiction is the jurisdiction under the provisions of Article 9 LOPJ, adding that "the civil courts operate only when the damage occurred does not occur by reason of or during work, but is linked to an employer's conduct outside the obligational content of the employment contract "(even though there was no unanimity in the solution, due to the dissenting opinion of Judge of this Court, Hon. Mr. Don Xavier O'Callaghan).
FIVE. Made this summary of the doctrine contained in the resolutions of this courtroom and orders of the Board of conflicts of competence, we must now resolve the issue in the two appeals filed in accident that killed worker D. Gabino, as a result of which his mother claimed compensation.
The Board considers that in these cases of civil claims resulting from a breach of an employment relationship created by an employment contract to determine who the competition is crucial to determine if the damage is attributed to a failure to work or conduct totally outside the employment contract. In the work the foundation for illicit held responsible is in breach of a rule governing such matters, either state or collectively. To narrow the shirking be studied, so if there is breach of duty to protect and qualification of the facts, in which the employer is required to act as such. Therefore, to be competent civil jurisdiction, the damage must be due to different rules from those governing the content of the employment relationship, because when there is a breach of that relationship is to be declared the jurisdiction of the labor courts.
opinion of this Court, therefore, breach of contract will work in cases where voluntary standards are violated or collective legal, regulatory it, because, according to the provisions of Article 1258 CC, the contracts require the moment of its perfection "[n] or only to compliance with the expressly agreed, but also all the consequences that, by nature, conform to good faith, use and the law. " And so, the obligations regarding the safety of workers are part of the content of the employment contract according to legal norms that regulate it and so:
1, Article 19 of the Statute of Workers states that " worker in the provision of services shall be entitled to effective protection of safety and hygiene, taking into account that article 5, d) ET includes labor rights within the "physical integrity and proper health and safety policy."
2 The Law 31/1995 of Occupational Risk Prevention, Article 14 says that "Workers are entitled to effective protection of safety and health at work. That right implies the existence a corresponding duty on employers to protect workers against occupational hazards. " Furthermore, Article 42 of this Law reads: "1. The failure of the employers of their obligations regarding risk prevention will lead to administrative responsibilities, as well as where appropriate, to criminal and civil liability for damages arising from such failure, determining the accountability framework that could lead the accident caused by the breach of security obligations without establishing yet , competition.
3 Article 127.3 LGSS (TR of 20 June 1994) states that "if the benefit has been to source factual circumstances involving criminal or civil liability of any person, including the employer, provision will actually meet the other conditions, by the manager, service or Mutual common accidents and diseases professionals, as appropriate, without prejudice to those responsibilities. In these cases, the worker or his heirs may demand compensation from the alleged criminal or civil liability. "
4 Section 123.3 LGSS (TR of 20 June 1994), to regulate the so-called surcharge benefits economic work accidents and occupational diseases stipulates in paragraph 3 that "The responsibility for regulating this Article is independent and compatible with that of all kinds, even criminal, arising from the breach."
According to the above, should be considered that workers' compensation liability arises from breach of statutory duty because the law is determining the obligational content of the employment contract. The safety requirement comes under strict employment contract, because it is part of the contractual content to establish the law of prevention of occupational risks in Article 14: this is a general duty of care embodied in law the content of the employment contract .
The Board, therefore, establishes the doctrine that by virtue of the provisions of Article 9 LOPJ, the employer's liability claims arising out of breach of contract Work should be the responsibility of the social courts.
SIX. Coming to the issue of competition alleged in the first ground of appeal raised by the Cooperative Society UNION and the application of ALVIC, SA, applying the above doctrine we must solve in the sense that competition should be left to the jurisdiction social. However, this case presents special characteristics, having been sued jointly with the contractor and subcontractor companies, others who have no working relationship with the accident victim. This is the technical work, the Technical Ingenio D. Jaime has been condemned the decision under appeal, but having failed in an appeal, the sentence becomes final, and society ALVIC, SA, owner of the work, which has relied on appeal. Therefore, we must consider whether to apply the doctrine established in the previous basis.
While there has been a breach of employment contract, having been sued in this procedure completely unrelated people to it, as with society today ALVIC appellant, SA, the statement must be excluded excess of jurisdiction, under the attractive vis civil jurisdiction established in Article 9.2 LOPJ must be declared jurisdiction of this court to entertain an action for damages filed by the plaintiff for the death of his son. Unable to split the case, this attractive vis also affect those defendants, one of which is now the appellant, who enjoyed a working relationship with the deceased worker.
For these reasons, we reject the first two grounds of the appeals filed by the subcontractor Cooperativa Andaluza "UNION" and society ALVIC, SA
2 º Appeal Andalusian cooperatives' UNION .
SEVEN. The second reason for this appellant relies on Article 1692, 3 LEC and specifically denounced the violation of section 359 LEC in conjunction with Article 248.3 LOPJ, causing helplessness for breach of the principle of effective judicial protection contained in Article 24 English Constitution. He complains that the contested decision did not resolve all procedural exceptions raised by the appellant, which were the lack of jurisdiction, lack of personality of the plaintiff for failing to prove the character of his claim, the legal flaw in the way of submitting the application and lack of passive legitimacy. Notes that in its opinion, the decision under appeal had ruled only on the first two exceptions, but not the other two. And going to solve directly, it has been alleged helplessness. Is correct as the appellant shows that the decision under appeal does not expressly resolved two exceptions proposed in response to demand, on the occurrence of a defect or procedural defect in the way of submitting the application and your own lack passive standing. STC 169/2002 of 30 September said that "[...] as we said in the ruling 215/1999 of 29 November, cited in turn by the Case 5 / 2001 of 15 January, "the opinion on the consistency of judicial resolution demands confronting the part of the sentence and the object of the process, defined by reference their subjective elements - parts-and objectives-cause order and "petitum-" so that in relation to the adequacy latter elements should extend both to the result that the litigant seeks to obtain as to the facts and legal arguments that support claim (for all judgments 139/1998 and 29/1999). "As stated in the ruling of this Court of March 6, 2007," The duty of consistency, it is settled doctrine of this Court, is the necessary adjustment to be given between "appeal" of the written guidelines of the decision process to see if it has awarded more than as requested, left unresolved issues raised or made on outside edges of the request, so that if you engage in any of these defects, the sentence will be inconsistent (SS. March 2, 2000, November 28 and December 20, 2006 and July 20, 2007).
However, the exception on lack of standing passively determined to be implied in the sentence appeal, since we are actually faced with a question affecting the merits, whether the defendant-appellant was or was not responsible for the accident and it was solved implicitly by the appeal decision today to order the appellant (SSTS May 20, 2002, December 29, 2006 and July 31 and September 18, 2007). Accordingly, it is not a procedural exception that prevents entry to examine the merits of the case. Not so with the exception relating to legal flaw in the way of submitting the application, which was not discussed and in relation to whom it is estimated that ground.
EIGHT. Dear this reason in part, must come to consider the exception unresolved appeal the ruling. The appellant raised the exception of legal flaw in the way of submitting the application, under Article 533.6 LEC 1881, because he understands that no action has clearly exercised, and considers that claimed some damage following the death of the worker, to be a breach of contract and not to a responsibility tort.
This exception must be rejected, since it must be understood that attends this defect when not clearly express "the facts and legal arguments, not fixed clearly what is requested, the person against whom the application is made and expression of the kind of action relied on, "so that it prevents the sentencing judge accurate and consistent (SSTS April 17, 1979, October 6, 1992). The application satisfies the requirements, so it must reject the objection raised.
NINE. Resolved the procedural issues raised in the appeal of the Cooperative Society "The Union" we come to examine the merits of his appeal.
The third ground of appeal, under Article 1692, 4 LEC infringement complaint for improper implementation of Article 1902 CC, as the appellant company performed the work under the direction of the technician, also convicted, but it incurs no responsibility, which should correspond to the technician who led the work, who was forced to take security measures.
This plea should be admitted because in fact the responsibility of the subcontractor, employer of the deceased worker, not guilty of liability, but has failed to fulfill contractual obligations in relation to the lack of security measures, as demonstrated in this case. However, applying the doctrine of equal results can not be estimated this plea. As noted above, the breach of contract of employment was caused by the breach of the rules on health and safety and this Court has declared itself competent to hear this appeal (Legal basis 6 º), so it should come to examine whether occurred or not the said breach giving rise to the obligation to respond (in the same direction, STS 5 January 2008). In the present case has been demonstrated negligence of the subcontractor, and that the deceased worker belonged to his staff.
relation to negligence and causation, the decision under appeal considered proven that according to the report of the inspector's own work and technical director of the work accident was caused by the apparent absence of security measures necessary "to that level the truss not provoke a transmission belts effort that led to jump the welds and the precipitation of the trusses of the structure that caused the tragic event." The sentence appeal states in relation to the appellant's participation in production damage, that liability "is configured by the absence of the most basic care in order to adopt security measures for workers in charge", which determines the allocation of the damage caused to the appellants and the rejection of this reason.
TENTH. The fourth plea, submitted under Article 1692, 4 LEC denounces the violation of article 4.1 CC misapplication. Considers that the contested decision applies the quantum of damages in accordance with the criteria of the scale fixed Liability Law and Insurance, where there is no legal vacuum, since the quantification responsibility for compensation for death is foreseen in the sector collective agreement, which must apply to be enforceable standard.
The reason is disallowed.
Indeed, we face a claim of liability based on fault of the employer, filed in accordance with Article 1902 CC. Therefore, the criteria for the quantification of damage should be civil, and this Court has understood that the set can be used in so-called "scales" by way of guidance (November 11, 2005 STS), because as stated in the sentence June 13, 2006 "The only principle that has to take into account the judge is the indemnity of the victim [...]" and without prejudice to be taken into account the amounts actually provided to the injured (SSTS of 8 October 2001 and December 31, 2003).
2 º Appeal ALVIC, SA.
ELEVENTH. The second reason for society ALVIC, SA is made under Article 1692, 4 LEC and denounces the violation of Articles 1902 and 1903 CC. Says that it is causing accidents has been clearly identified in the evidence in the contested decision, which is the inspection report work that states that construction of the steel structure that collapsed "had not taken the necessary measures to prevent risks, and the coach's statement, also condemned, who pointed out the technical reasons why the ropes broke and caused the accident. " She also observes that despite this, the responsibility of the company ALVIC, SA is "within the ambit of that work began without a license, saying that although this aspect has only one administrative impact, however the license application requires the completion of a project that must contain safety standards to ensure the integrity of workers and the appropriate construction of the ship ", hence terminating the responsibility of the developer, which denied the appellant because the principle of causality" requires to assess the agent's fault that the result is a natural consequence of adequate and sufficient of the agent's conduct "and that" there must necessarily conclusive evidence on the causal link between behavior and production staff so that damage becomes apparent guilt that requires repair. "The appellant believes that cause of the accident is due to construction problems and, therefore, outside the owner of the work, preventing them responsible.
This ground must be estimated.
The question is who should be charged against the damage incurred an obligation to respond. As stated in the statement of September 6, 2005, in this case we have a strict allocation of course, often been presented in the case as a matter of causation. To this end the above sentence states: "We are in the case, before an objective allocation problem, which has often been presented to us as a matter of causation, without demarcate precisely between the locking operation of the act or act without which it is inconceivable that another fact or event is considered the first effect or consequence (causal), and that is to enucleate the overall damage that may have harmful event occurred which are compensable and what not. That is, avoid being put in charge of the head all the consequences of his conduct is cause (allocation objective in its own right), to "get by" the obligation to repair the damage that is compensable under the guidelines offered by regulatory system. "The sentence of 10 February 2006 says that" It needs to be attributed to who is to be held accountable, in whole or in part, of a damaging event, any conduct, active or passive, which has influenced triggering the result, and if all that can be attributed to the defendants is the organization of the party, so if it is relevant in the field of material or physical causation is not sufficient by itself to generate the allocation or legal causation "(in the same direction, SSTS of September 6, 2005, 21 January, 2 March 1930 and 12 November and 7 December 2006 and January 5, 2007). The fact of having started the work without a license, in addition to sanctions administrative nature which could lead, not objectively possible to attribute responsibility to the promoter caused by the accident, since this behavior is not sufficient alone to confer legal causation (in one case very similar, Ruling May 6, 2000).
TWELFTH. The estimate of the second ground of appeal filed by the company ALVIC, SA relieve this Court to broach the third of the grounds for appeal.
THIRTEEN. The estimate in part on the grounds of appeal raised by the Sociedad Cooperativa Andaluza "THE UNION" determines is not proper to impose the costs of this appeal to the appellant.
The estimate of the second ground of appeal raised by the legal representation of society ALVIC, SA determines its action and the appeal of the decision under appeal. Consequently, assuming the instance, it should dismiss the complaint against the company ALVIC, SA. Also, when this resource estimate, it should not imposing the same costs. Imposed on the plaintiff Ms. Juana the costs at first instance by the intervention of ALVIC, SA
the foregoing, on behalf of King and the authority of the English people
BUGS
1 º. It is estimated in part the appeal of Sociedad Cooperativa Andaluza "The Union" against the Judgement of Section 2nd from the Audiencia Provincial de Jaén, dated April 14, two thousand, delivered in roll Appeal No. 423/98.
2 º. Consequently, it rejects the objection of a legal defect in the background of submitting the application.
3 º. In other respects the ruling is upheld under appeal, including the end on the coast.
4 º. He has held the appeal of ALVIC, SA against the same sentence.
5 º. Judgement was appealed to wed instead demand absolve ALVIC, SA
6º. Imponer a la actora Dª Juana las costas causadas en primera instancia por la intervención de ALVIC, S.A.
7º. No imponer a Sociedad cooperativa andaluza "La Unión" las costas causadas por su recurso de casación.
8º. No imponer las costas causadas por el recurso de casación presentado por ALVIC, S.A.
Líbrese a la mencionada Audiencia la certificación correspondiente, con devolución de los autos y rollo de apelación remitidos.
Así por esta nuestra sentencia, que se insertará en la COLECCIÓN LEGISLATIVE passing copies for this purpose, we pronounce it, sign and send Xiol .- Juan Antonio Román García Varela Rios .- .- .- Xavier O'Callaghan Muñoz Jesús Marín Corbal Castán Francisco Fernández .- .- .- José Gabriel Ramón Ferrándiz Jose Antonio Seijas Quintana Carceller .- .- Antonio Salas Luis Montes Vicente Roca Trias Incarnation Penadés .- .- Signature.
PUBLICATION .- Read and was published earlier ruling by the Hon. SR. D. Roca Trias embodiment, Rapporteur has been in the process of the present case, being held Public Hearing the First Chamber of the Supreme Court on the day Today, what we as Secretary thereof, certify.
Why Do Guys Like Nighties
Where Is The Pressure Point On My Ankle To Start
Step