Thursday, October 18, 2007

Benefits Of No Underwear

Eviction for nonpayment of a monthly -

Date: October 30, 2009
Body: Supreme Court
Room: Civil I, Section 1


In the town of Madrid, to October 30 of two thousand and nine

The First Chamber of the Supreme Court consisting of Judges indicated in the margin, has seen the 2629/2004 appeal brought by defendant Don Anselmo, represented before this court by Attorney Don Domingo José Collado Miller, against the ruling dated October 15, 2004 under Section 9 of the Provincial Court of Madrid in the appeal No. 351/03 arising from the verbal trial Car No 651/02 the Court of First Instance No. 21, Madrid, on farm urban eviction for nonpayment of rent. Respondent was the applicant SALOBRE, SA, who appeared represented by Counsel Dona Leticia Calderón Galán.

FACTUAL BACKGROUND

FIRST .- On July 2, 2002 the appeal today, brackish, SA filed a lawsuit against the now Anselmo appellant, which was channeled by oral trial procedures, sentencing requesting that the following statements

'a) Approve the eviction of the defendant, the leased property, forcing him to vacate it and leave the full and free disposition of my client, under penalty of release, if not effected

b) order the defendant to pay the amount of the rent for the month of June 2002 amounted to 4082.02 Euros statutory interest.

c) order the defendant to pay the amount of rent for the months that elapsed until delivery Judgement, if he has not vacated the leased premises.

d) order the defendant to pay the costs. "

For Otrosí say was announced, for the purposes of the stated in Article 22 of Law No. 4 of Civil Procedure, that "the lessee shall not invalidate the eviction as it did on a previous occasion."

SECOND .- Turner claim to the Court of First Instance No. 21, Madrid, resulting in the present trial No. 651/02 verbal eviction, said the defendant and both parties appeared at the hearing , it was held, ratifying the plaintiff in his claims, and making the defendant in the process of answering opposition to the actions of claims adjudication and accumulated income, arguing, in essence, that had entered the amount of rent due and that this must involve the innervation of the eviction.

THIRD .- Received the suit to trial and followed by his paperwork, the Hon. Mr. Magistrate Judge ruled that Judge dated February 28, 2003 in which it reads as follows:

"granting the application filed by the Solicitor of the Courts Ms. Leticia Calderón Galán on behalf of Salobre entity, SA, declared the eviction of commercial premises "Store B" in the C / Velázquez, no. 29, Madrid, for the defendant D. Anselmo, who was sentence to vacate, empty and expedite local referral.

the costs are imposed on the defendant. "

FOURTH .- Filed by the defendant against that decision on appeal, which was processed under No 351/03 of Section 9 of the Provincial Court of Madrid, the court ruled on 15 October date 2004 with the following decision:

"That dismissing the appeal brought by the legal representation of Don Anselmo, against the Judgement delivered by the Hon. Mr. Justice Court of First Instance number 21 of this capital, dated Feb. 28, two thousand three, cars there followed an oral proceeding under number 651/02, we CONFIRM AND CONFIRM the said resolution, expressly imposition of the said appellant of the costs incurred in this appeal. "

FIFTH .- The defendant and appellant prepared and then appealed, pursuant to art. 477, paragraph 2.3 º LEC, citing the existence of appellate interest in the form of conflicting jurisprudence of Provincial courts both in relation to the possibility of undermining the eviction action for nonpayment by previous payment to the summons for trial, having already given a previous enervation, as in the exercise of the right to collect rent with good faith and in a non-abusive, according to articles 7.1 and 2 of the Civil Code, but also cites as infringed upon, their relation to the substantive issue, Articles 22.4 and 439.3 of the LEC in connection with Articles 451 and 452 of the same.

SIXTH .- People
both parties before this court by the attorneys named above, by order of January 22 2008, and once completed the processing of claims prescriptive partially agreed to admit the complaint in connection with the violation of Article 7.1 and 2, CC. and as regards the existence of contradictory doctrine of Provincial Courts, regarding consideration as a mere delay or default as true of dissolving the payment of income outside the contractually agreed deadline and that this application for eviction, but before the arraignment to defendant does not admit, however, based on the ground provided for in Article 483.2.1 ° of the LEC, in relation to the same rule 477.1, the reason for contesting the second, based on the violation of procedural rules by raising questions adjectival material beyond the scope of this appeal.

then the rental applicant, respondent filed its notice of opposition, which ends up begging to reject the appeal and confirmed the Judgement fully contested.

SEVENTH .- By order of September 18 of this year was appointed rapporteur that it is at this step and agreed to resolve the appeal without holding the hearing, pointing to a vote and decision on 1 October following that has taken place.

has been Reporter Judge Hon. Mr. D. Francisco Marin Castan,

LEGAL FIRST .-
again subjected to the prosecution of this Court an appeal, based on the existence of appellate interest in the form of points and issues to that there is "conflicting jurisprudence of the Provincial Court, where the dispute revolves around whether, in an eviction process of urban property for nonpayment of income, promoted after another that had already enervated declared the action under the first paragraph of Art. 4 of art. 22 LEC 2000, or not to order the eviction despite the fact that the defendant pay or appropriate the rent owed only a few days delay to the deadline stipulated in the contract and before being summoned to the hearing of verbal, and that while the appellant is opposed to the termination of the contract on the basis of which was always willingness to pay, even if it did late, the decision under appeal, confirming the one issued in the first degree, follows the approach of considering the mere delay as a real breach.

Before discussing in depth the legal question is necessary to note the facts on which the contested decision supports his decision:

a) On April 10, 1985 the defendant signed with the plaintiff a lease on business premises "Store B" situated at number 29 of Madrid Velasquez, with corresponding income for 2002 of EUR 48,984.24 per year including VAT (4082.02 euros per month), which should be met by months in advance. According to the second clause, included in the conditions of the contract, the back, "the delay of fifteen days in the payment of rent is estimated as sufficient cause to initiate the eviction."

b) On July 5, 1998 Court number 57 of Madrid, in the process of eviction followed between the same parties, issued a decision declaring the action called into question.

c) On July 2, 2002 the rental Salobre, SA claims filed for rents and eviction for nonpayment against Mr. Anselmo tenant for the rent owed for the month of June that year, amounting to 4,082, 02 euros. That application was declared admissible on 30 July.

d) In the lawsuit, and through Otrosí, indicated that no action could weaken already been done by a previous occasion, although the Court did not mention in the order of 30 July.

e) On September 9 the plaintiff advised the court that the rent had sido satisfecha, por lo que solicitaba se siguiera el juicio sólo para resolver sobre el desahucio , lo que así se acordó por providencia de 15 de octubre de 2002, aunque indicándose que podía enervarse la renta pese a que la demanda indicaba lo contrario, celebrándose la vista el 25 de febrero de 2003, y acreditándose que el importe de la deuda arrendaticia había sido remitido a la arrendadora por giro urgente el 10 de julio de 2002.

Partiendo de ese factum , la sentencia de apelación confirma la decisión del Juzgado de estimar la demanda y la acción de desahucio en ella ejercitada, valorando la conducta de la parte arrendataria de no pagar en el plazo contractualmente stipulated as a real breach and not as simple decisional delay or late performance, and that because the contract clearly stated that the rent be paid monthly in advance and that the mere delay of fifteen days in payment was sufficient to initiate eviction , concurred situation in this case from the time that the tenant had not paid within that period the rent for the month of June 2002 (4082.02 euros), the amount owed to date filed for eviction ( July 2nd that year) and did not meet until eight days after that (July 10, 2002), notwithstanding an order to determine the default that was only adequate income, or the fact that he was paid before the arraignment of the defendant, because he was already aware that the enervation of an eviction in the past, say what he said the order of admission of claim, legally prevented a second enervation (both in the light of above 1563 of the LEC in 1881 as under current 22.4 CEL 2000), so that from the time of its obligation to pay rent June adjudicative knew too well the consequences, no avoidable in this case, that could result from this new default, ruling that the Court will promptly collect the rent the tenant incurs abuse of rights.

After not beyond the stage of admission of violations relating to procedural provisions (Articles 22.4, 439.3, 451 and 452 of the LEC), has been reduced this action to determine whether there is interest in the mode of appellate jurisprudence contradictory Hearings provincial, first, the possibility that the ruling excluded in invalidate the eviction action by nonpayment by a previous payment to the summons for trial, even if it had taken place and a previous enervation and secondly, closely connected with the above, whether incurred or not the landlord abuse of rights who exercise their right to collect income in such circumstances. Regarding the first issue, the appellant argues that the "lower case" has responded unevenly, with positions favorable to consider the late payment of a tenant but not as late as a real breach, to which only the enervation , if possible, could prevent decisive; Urged success of the action, and others who follow the opposite approach, advocated by the appellant, to understand that any payment from the tenant prior to their location and summons for trial, that is, when yet there was no knowledge of the suit had been filed against him, is not a non-adjudicatory, as there will deliberately disobeyed the payment but merely a delay in discharge. As for the possible abuse of rights, it is argued in essence that the lessor, prompting a lawsuit for eviction after being returned only receiving a monthly income, has sought to resolve the contract at all costs, regardless of the will of tenant to meet its obligations, albeit with delay, which is a clear case of abuse.

The plaintiff, as contested, opposed the appeal on substantive grounds, arguing, in essence, that the performance of that party can not be labeled as abusive or contrary to good faith, but only as fully set the terms of the contract, as stipulated in the same, to cause subsequent, two weeks delay in the payment of rent.

SECOND .- The contract dispute that this action pertains to whether, strictly excluded by the second paragraph of Art. 4 of art. LEC 22, 2000, the possibility of a second innervation of the eviction, or not proceeding with a second application for eviction by nonpayment of rent (in breach of the duty to pay it within contractually established) when the tenant pays the due after that and brought before the summons is a matter to which this Court and has responded in its statement of July 24, 2008 (Appeal 508/02), rescission of an appeal for cassation interest in the modality also "contradictory jurisprudence of the provincial courts, which, after marrying the sentence appeal contains the following statement: "2 .- Declaring the case law that payment of the rent of the lease of business premises, out of time and after filing the eviction action does not preclude the applicability of resolution rental agreement, and that although demand is based on the non-payment of one month's rent without the landlord must come to support the tenant usually delayed in the payment of regular income "doctrine has been reiterated in the latest of March 26, 2009 (application 1507/2004) and necessarily has to sit to resolve this action.

Projecting on the case doctrine of those judgments must be concluded that judgment that was issued before the previous ones, is fully consistent with his case, as in the present case, as in those discussed then, had brokered an earlier enervation of action and had not paid the rent was paid after filing the lawsuit, to be fully applicable to this appeal the reasons given by this Court to explain the existence a real non-adjudicatory, referring to the burden of the obligation to pay rent according to art. TR 114-1 ª LAU-1964, "which makes a single monthly payment default, as happens in this case, it is seen as cause for termination of the contract and not as a mere delay in performance," and the absence of abuse of rights by the landlord in case of default, exercises the eviction action , to which, following the statement by the ruling of March 26, 2009, may be added, on the one hand, when the actual contract provides, as is the case, a maximum period of delay in payment (the second clause speaks of two weeks), expressly providing that after the expiration of the term, the landlord may initiate eviction, no sense to ask whether a delay is longer than non-adjudicatory or merely delay, as the parties themselves have set as default justification of eviction, and the contract itself will have to sit under Art. CC 1255, or else, that consideration of other time-limits by the courts, to distinguish the mere delay of non-adjudicatory lead to absolute legal uncertainty created a certain risk of arbitrariness rather than judicial discretion, without prejudice to the circumstances of the case itself can and should be addressed to assess whether or not there has been or breach of contract, and finally, that excessive protection of tenants, especially if borders on paternalism, can generate undesirable overall effect of retracting the supply of homes for rent by the fear of the owners have to bear the repeated breaches of the tenants, especially since in many cases the need for the landlord to collect rent on time can be as compelling as that of the tenant to have a home.

The solution pointed to by this Court in those judgments, in favor of deeming the mere failure to delay in payment of an allowance, and not to admit the value enervatorio payment made after the filing demand, is, as the last of the aforementioned resolutions, perfect accommodation in the rental agreement, legislative developments towards greater protection of the landlord against tenant abuses. In this regard, affirms the decision of 26 March 2009 which, while meeting regulation leases socio-economic circumstances of each historical period, the incumbent legislature set the rules and judges and courts interpret them according to the criteria of art. 3 CC and apply them accordingly, so that, one of these criteria, the care of social reality, and certainly also the adequacy of the provision to the Constitution, "not fit to ignore that the evolution of urban rental agreement legislation since the Royal Decree-Law 2 / 1985 of 30 April on measures of economic policy has been responding to a limitation of the tenant's rights in the temporary extension of the rental agreement and above all, to a progressive strengthening of the protection of the landlord against the tenant's breach of contract, a good example of which is to reduce the chances of enervation of the eviction action for nonpayment than one in art. LEC 22.4 2000 and the inclusion of the demands on urban farm evictions for nonpayment of income or amounts due in field of rapid pointing trials set by D. Additional 5th LEC introduced in 2000 by the LO 19/2003 of 23 December ', concluding that "the law itself is urban rental agreement, therefore, that in certain circumstances just equating cumplimientotardío by the lessee of its obligation pay rent to a final breach justifying termination of the contract at the request of the landlord. "

is therefore the evolution of the rental agreement to a higher standard care or protection of the landlord against the tenant's breach of contract which precludes granting the payment in the second value enervatorio lawsuit that advocates against the wording of Article 22.4 LEC. In this regard, the statement of March 26, 2009, and discards the thesis here proposed the appellant, reasoning that "set the enervation as a tenant's right to contest a landlord's right as essential as it is to receive the lease price right This correlative to the obligation of the tenant also essential to pay (arts. 1543, 1546 and 1555-1 º CC), so that the enervation is presented less as a right as the tenant an opportunity to avoid eviction legally configured on each historical moment from a social point. " So "It is difficult to sustain, when he has mediated an eviction action innervation and the landlord brought eviction later another one nuevoimpago income in due time, the tenant can avoid eviction by paying the rent due before being summoned to view. First, because under the ruling of the Plenum of the judges of this court of January 20, 2009 (rec. 2693/03), which is the constitution of the debtor in arrears, it begins with the filing of the lawsuit against him and not to suemplazamiento, and secondly, because allowing the tenant the contractual behavior carries the risk of developing the tardy payment of income weakening correspondingly the landlord's right to timely, since it will be impossible to know for sure if the file your claim, however it is founded, will end ono thriving since its viability will depend on the facts and be certain the relevant legal basis for the application itself as purely random factor that decides whether or not the tenant to pay before being summoned to the hearing. For these reasons, Art. 3 of art. LEC 439 2000 in relation to par. 3, Art. 440 may not be interpreted as meaning that, when the law makes it impossible to invalidate the eviction, it is conditional on the known arrendatariohaya this impediment before paying out of time, for while weaken the possibility of action before the hearing itself must be known to the defendant tenant, according to Art. 440.3 in relation to the first paragraph of Art. 4 of art. 22, both of the LEC, 2000, encambio the impossibility of enervation, which also refers to Art. 3 of art. 439 of the Act, can be understood as an indication of eviction demand addressed to both the tenant does not respect the court itself to make mention of that possibility and not included in the summons the defendant to the eye.

And if these reasons are that the lessee actually failed in its obligation to pay be cause for the landlord to legally promote the eviction, it seems clear that in no case the lessee is limited to seeking a process a legally recognized contract law and may engage in conduct contrary to the requirements of Article 7.1 and 2 of the Civil Code , it also clarifies the much-quoted statement of 26 March 2009 that "within the careful balance between the rights of landlord and tenant legislation seeks urban rental agreement in every historical period, with rules that protect the tenant, as the extension forced before and the minimum duration of contract now, and others that protect the landlord against breaches of it, as the current reduction of innervation of the eviction opportunities to one, the landlord is not indifferent to the time you pay the rent stipulated, and the abuse of rights is not in the landlord intends to terminate the contract for failure to pay timely income as the tenant to continue his tardiness. So the enervation of eviction can not be understood as a "procedural law" that undermine the substantive law of the tenant who paid rent on time, but as an opportunity to carefully manage the law itself from a social point of each historical , and hence not fit to force the landlord to file a lawsuit after another when it is not dependent him the time their claims will be known by the tenant and, instead, it does depend on the timely payment of rent. "

For all these reasons it must reject the plea and thus the appeal.

THIRD .- Consistent with the arts. 398.1 487.2 and 394.1 in relation to all of the LEC, 2000, the Court rejects the appeal and impose costs to the appellant.

the foregoing, on behalf of King and the authority of the English people.

BUGS

1 .- DISMISS THE APPEAL brought by defendant Don Anselmo, represented before this court by the Attorney Don Domingo José Collado Miller, against the ruling dated October 15, 2004 under Section 9 of the Provincial Court of Madrid in the appeal No. 351/03

2 .- impose costs against the appellant.

Rid
that Court for certification, to return the car and roll Hall.

Thus by this our sentence, to be inserted in the Collection of Laws copies passing the necessary effect, we pronounce it, sign and send .- John Xiol Rios.-Francisco Antonio Marin Castan.-Jose Antonio Seijas Quintana .- Roca Encarnacion Trias.-signed and initialed.

PUBLICATION .- Read and was published earlier ruling by the Hon. SR. D. Francisco Marin Castan, Rapporteur has been in the process of the present case, Public Hearing to be held the First Chamber of the Supreme Court, today, of which as Secretary thereof, certify.

Ap Biology Lab 5 Conclusion Ap Biology Lab 5?

Tenancies Tenancies - IBI Calculation

Date: November 7, 2008
Body:
Supreme Court Room: Civil I, Section 1


Viewed by First Chamber of the Supreme Court, composed of Judges set aside, the appeal against the ruling by the Audiencia Provincial de Alicante, Section Five, as a result of cars, number 128/02 oral proceedings, proceedings before the Trial Benidorm Instance number 8 on eviction and claim amount, which was brought by Mrs. Celestina, represented by the Solicitor of the Courts Ms. Irene Martinez Lopez, which is under appeal Doña Marina represented by Attorney Don José Luis Ferrer Recuero.

FACTUAL BACKGROUND

FIRST. Before the Court of First Instance number 8 Benidorm, were seen in the file, view eviction and claim amount, promoted at the request of Doña Celestina, to Doña Marina.

For the plaintiffs claim was made under the statutory requirements, which requested prior allegation of the facts and legal grounds: "... issue in their day sentence for declaring the contract avoided in lease for nonpayment income and similar amounts and order the defendant to pay Real Estate Tax Rate and refuse collection due for periods totaling of 883.98, plus legal interest of this sum, and the payment of all costs that are caused in this lawsuit. "

Declared admissible claim, the defendant replied stating as facts and the legal basis as appropriate, and ended up pleading to the court: "... in the decision handed agreed partially upheld the complaint, ordering the defendant to pay the amount of 883.98, which have already been paid, the action being dismissed resolution lease for non-payment, which must be acquitted the defendant, each party must pay the costs of your instance and shared by half, to be a partial estimate demand. "

By
Court ruling was issued on 22 June 2002, part of which is as follows:" FAULT: That full estimating the application filed by Mr Cabanes Marhuenda Attorney, on behalf and representation of Doña Celestina against Doña Marina, I declare and declare the lease, with reference to housing located in Benidorm, C / DIRECCION000 No NUM000, NUM001 NUM002 (formerly No NUM001, NUM003 NUM002), binds to both parties , and therefore, I condemn and condemn the defendant to vacate within the legal time, allow free and open to the plaintiff that dwelling on pain that, if not done, there will be launch and its costs.

Also, I must condemn and condemn Dona Marina to pay the plaintiff the amount of EIGHT HUNDRED EIGHTY-THREE EUROS AND NINETY-EIGHT CENTS (883.98), expressly imposing interest and costs incurred in this procedure the defendant ".

SECOND. A petition was filed an appeal which was accepted, and pursued it, the Audiencia Provincial de Alicante, Section Five, issued a decision dated February 6, 2003, as part is as follows: "Fault: With partial estimate of the appeal deducted against the ruling of the Court of First Instance No. 8 Benidorm dated June 22, 2002 in the proceedings emanating this roll, we reverse and reverse in part the resolution, and absolve Dona Marina in demand on resolution lease that brought Doña Celestina. That decision is confirmed as regards the order to pay 883.98 euros. Rejecting the challenge articulated by that applicant. No special statement on costs in both instances. ".

THREE. The Attorney Dona Irene López Martínez, representing Doña Celestina, formalized appeal that based on the following reasons:

Reason first. Contrary interpretation of the Board "a quo" to the mainstream legal doctrine sitting by numerous hearings regarding the qualification of Property Tax as the amount treated as income.

Reason
second. It is based on the basis of the violation committed by the trial court of the scientific doctrine and jurisprudence issued by other hearings on the concept of rate of Garbage as an amount treated as income to the effect that its failure to rise to full resolution the contract.

FOUR. Evacuated transfer conferred Attorney Don José Luis Ferrer Recupero, representing Doña Marina, lodged a challenge to the use and terms pleading with this court: "... sentencing deciding his dismissal, with costs against the appellant."

FIVE. By Order of this Court dated October 30, 2007 is agreed the acceptance of this resource.

SIX. Has not been applied by all parties holding a public hearing, noted for voting and ruling on October 30, 2008, which has taken place.

has been Reporter Judge Hon. D. CLEMENTE AUGER LIÑÁN

LEGAL

I.-The dispute which gave rise to this appeal was initiated by the appellant here, Doña Celestina cumulative exercise resolution action lease contract and eviction for nonpayment of the last five installments of IBI and garbage rates and claim amounts owed by such concepts. The procedure is directed against Doña Marina, verbal contract leasing the property from 1974 situated in the Calle DIRECCION000 NUM000 number, NUM001 NUM002 (before NUM001 number, NUM003 NUM002 ) In the town of Benidorm.

The expected court ruling declaring a demand full eviction and payment of amounts due, and although not considered non-payment of IBI as the amount treated as income for purposes of cause for termination of contract However, it does consider the failure to pay garbage fees supporting this cause resolution to fit it within the concept of providing the former LAU.

The sentence was appealed by both sides, making the appellant here, despite the full estimation of demand, against the legal argument not to consider the IBI as the amount treated as income.

The Court of Appeal annulled the decision partially reverses the ruling on the eviction by failing to consider that non-payment of IBI and garbage rates to determine cause of eviction and maintains the order to pay of the amounts due.

The applicant lodged an appeal on the basis of paragraph 3 of Article 477.2 of the LEC as there is interest appellate review in the procedure by conflicting jurisprudence of provincial courts in relation to two issues: first, whether the default of IBI can determine cause resolution of the lease entered into under the LAU of 1,964. The second question, whether the default rate of litter can be considered as an amount treated as income as possible, event of default, determine the resolution of lease .

SECOND. For procedural reasons, be discussed first, the second ground of appeal. This reason is based on the basis of the violation committed by the trial court of the scientific doctrine and jurisprudence issued by other hearings on the concept of rate of waste as much income assimilated to the effect that its failure to rise to the decision and void the contract, in this regard I note that the legal issue is resolved by applying a jurisprudence that has taken in this case the Fifth Section of the Audiencia Provincial de Alicante ".

the development of this reason it appears the disagreement of the appellant with the basis of right fourth of the contested decision it believes the garbage rates are not treated as income amounts that can determine the event of default, the resolution of lease . The appellant considers that the entry into force of the Urban Leases Act of 1994 allows Second transitional provision, 10.5 pass on the costs of services and supplies and therefore, as the garbage fee passed on to the tenant an amount is treated as income amount can determine cause for termination in accordance with 114.1 of the LAU of 1,964.

However, the appellant has not properly established the existence of interest appellate argued, therefore, basing it in the second paragraph of number 3 in conjunction with ordinal 3 of number 1, both of Article 477 of the Act Civil Procedure for Provincial Hearing conflicting jurisprudence, as in the original preparation are mentioned only in a different sense of the sentence appeal, various Provincial Courts Judgments, without at least two sentences are the same Court and Section, and in the meaning of the sentence appeal, only the approach of the contested decision is followed by another statement of the same Court and Section that the contested decision date, with to be fulfilled and only part of the equation that this Board considers necessary to establish appellate interest for this cause (two sentences of the same audience or Section as opposed to two separate judgments in respect of the same audience or section). Furthermore, not all statements made remain the approach advocated by the appellant on this point because most of them refer to the concept of IBI income as an amount comparable to but not all relate to the rate comparable to waste as much income. This implies that, at this stage of the proceedings, the plea of \u200b\u200binadmissibility of Article 483.2.3 ° in relation to Article 477.2,3 and 3, both of the Civil Procedure Law, becoming a cause for dismissal, that the Board proceed already been followed in other similar cases of processed under the current resources of the new Civil Procedure Act (and, SSTS 18.04.2005, on an application 1547/2002, 17.07.2008, on an application 3308/2001, and 09.01.2008 in 2892 / 2002 resource).

Therefore, this plea must be rejected

THREE. In the first ground of appeal, the appellant alleges "contrary interpretation of the Board" a quo "of the mainstream legal doctrine sitting by numerous hearings regarding the qualification of Property Tax as the amount treated as income. Indeed, the ruling of the 5th Section of the Provincial Court of Alicante, in interpreting Article 114, section 1 of the LAU in 1964 regarding classification of the term "amounts treated as income" has broken numerous legal doctrine seated as is clear from their grounds and the contents of the appeal decision "

The appellant appealed of appeal under ordinal 3 of Article 477.2 of the Code of Civil Procedure justifying the issue of the existence of "interest appellate review" by conflicting jurisprudence of provincial courts in relation to the consideration of IBI as the amount treated as income for purposes of resolution of the lease. This interest has been justified appellate review under the terms required by this Court because it provides such judgments in favor of this view of the Audiencia Provincial de Santa Cruz de Tenerife, 22 May 1998, 15 April 2000 and 1 April 2000 and in opposed sense, maintaining the contrary view is put the sentence appeal, which in turn cited Case the same audience and section 21 October 1999, April 19, 2000, 22 March 2000 and 21 December 2001.

The reason has to be estimated.

This Court has had occasion to rule on the legal question raised by the appellant, through decision of the plenary of 12 January 2007 in the following sense: "Declaring jurisprudence that the failure of the tenant's tax Real Estate in housing leases in force at the time of entry into force of the new Urban Leases Act of November 24, 1994, must be regarded as cause for termination within the ª Article 114-1 of the revised Urban Leases Act of 1964. "The legal basis for this assertion is contained in the Third Legal Grounds of the resolution which states:" When the case 1 st Article 114 refers to similar amounts Income is alluding to those whose payment is to take the tenant by law, using an open formula must be supplemented with that at all times permitted by applicable law. If under the current text of 1964 were, in some cases, the corresponding differences in the cost of services and supplies and those resulting from the impact of the amount of work carried out by the landlord, now regard the text of the new law leads to the conclusion that the new tenant's obligation to pay the amount of IBI has to deserve equal consideration, so that its failure-as is the failure of a monetary obligation added essential to the payment of income-empowers the landlord to seek a termination of the contract. Otherwise would force the landlord to undertake an annual exercise action claim against the defaulting tenant of an annual obligation of which is to respond while the contract is in force, which involves regular basis the necessary assimilation of these effects the obligation also periodic payment of rent. Moreover, the interpretation of the rules according to its spirit and purpose (Article 3 of the Civil Code) also has to consider the case of Article 114-1 resolutory meetings of the Urban Leases Act of 1964 has to understand now, default by the lessee of the property tax, while such a rule tends to protect the landlord against the tenant defaults on obligations obligate conditions, such as this, and meaningless estimate that the obligation imposed on contracts housing lease entered into after the entry into force of the new Act Urban Lease 1994, with the effect of dissolving its non-compliance (Article 27.2 a), and extended such lessee's obligation also to previous contracts governed by the 1964 Act, operate for the first resolution-in terms of which the legislator less protective immunity, and not for the latter covered by a right of indefinite extension, in which the maximum protection afforded to the tenant must be matched by a strict compliance with its obligations. "

having been resolved question raised by the appellant as aforesaid, and being contrary to this doctrine, maintained by the ruling under appeal, there has been a breach of Article 114.1 of the Consolidated ª the Tenancies Act approved by Decree n º 4.104/1964 of 24 December to consider the IBI no unpaid by the lessee as cause for termination of lease agreement between the parties.

In accordance with Article 487.2 LEC, having been an infringement of the rules applicable to resolve the issue in the process of the interpretation given to it by this Court, must marry the contested decision, it is the duty of this Court, by the positive effect on the jurisdiction, take the instance, and having considered accredited by the Provincial Court, according to the evidence examined, the non-payment of property tax receipts the years 1997, 1998, 1999, 2000 and 2001, this statement has not been distorted in this office and that is the factual basis Case, unchanged on appeal, should the partial annulment of the contested decision, declaring the contract void and of housing lease located in NUM000 Goldfinch Street, NUM001 NUM002 (before NUM003 NUM002 NUM001 number) in the town of Benidorm between Doña Marina and Doña Celestina debiéndose condemn Ms. Marina to vacate the dwelling on legal term under penalty of release, confirming the other pronouncements of the contested decision, in terms of ordering payment of 838.98 euros for non-payment of IBI and garbage rates from 1,997 to 2,001 years.

FOUR. In accordance with Article 398.2 of the Code of Civil Procedure is not appropriate for costs of this action, imposing the costs at first instance under Article 394 of the same body of law to the party that has been rejected all his claims, that is, to this appeal and defendant in the main action, while maintaining the delivery of the no order for costs of the appeal under article 398.2 of the LEC.

the foregoing, on behalf of King and the authority of the English people

BUGS

We should declare and declare HAVE PLACE IN PART to the appeal made by Doña Celestina, represented by Prosecutor of the Tribunals Doña María José Millán Valero against the ruling on appeal on 6 February 2003 by the Audiencia Provincial de Alicante, Section Five in the roll number 33/2003, and in virtue:

1 º. Declared jurisprudence of this Division assimilation income urban rental agreement amounts due IBI for unpaid

2 .- The house partially judgment, keeping the ruling on the defendant's conviction Ms Marina to pay the amount of 883.98 for non-payment of property tax and garbage fees the years from 1997 to 2001.

3 .- Assuming the roles of body solves the lease for the apartment located in the street DIRECCION000 NUM000, NUM001 NUM002 (before NUM003 NUM002 NUM001 number) in the town of Benidorm between Marina and Queen Doña Celestina Ms Marina condemning to vacate the dwelling on legal term under penalty of release.

4 .- It impose the costs at first instance the defendant without a specific statement of those incurred in the appeal.

5 .- There is no express declaration of payment of costs incurred in this appeal.

Rid
the Court referred to the relevant certificate to back the cars and Roll Hall
sent

Thus by this our sentence, to be inserted in the Collection of Laws copies passing the necessary effect, we pronounced , sign and send Xiol Juan Antonio Rios. Jesus Corbal Fernández.Clemente Liñán.Rubricado Auger.

PUBLICATION .- Read and was published earlier ruling by the Hon. SR. D. Clemente Auger Linan, Rapporteur has been in the process of the present case, being held Public Hearing the First Chamber of the Supreme Court, today, of which as Secretary thereof, certify.

Friday, October 5, 2007

Why Does Someone Slip Into A Coma

pension food for the children

Date: July 5, 2010
Body: Supreme Court
Room: Civil I, Section 1
Speaker: ENCARNACION ROCA TRIAS


Seen by the Board First the Supreme Court, composed of Their Excellencies. Mr. Justices indicated in the margin, The appeal, before the Audiencia Provincial de Madrid, Section 24 meetings, by Ms. Candelaria, represented by the Solicitor of the Courts Ms. Maria del Carmen Ortiz Cornago against the sentence pronounced by that Court and Section, on November 10, 2006, in Reel Appeal No. 483/06, which heard the appeal filed at the time against the sentence that had pronounced, the Court of First Instance number 25 of Madrid, in divorce proceedings about No 269/05. Appear before this Board Attorney María del Carmen Ortiz Cornago, and on behalf of Ms Candelaria, acting of appellant, the Attorney Albarracín María Pascual, on behalf of D. Obdulio, as defendant.

FACTUAL BACKGROUND

FIRST. Before the Court of First Instance number 25 of Madrid, filed for divorce Ms. Candelaria, against D. Obdulio. The Claim Appeals reads as follows: ".... statement issued at the time in declaring the dissolution of marriage by divorce mentioned between spouses, with all the legal effects inherent in this statement, and enact the following measures:

1 .- CUSTODY. Doña Candelaria and Don Obdulio continue exercising joint custody of their children.

2 .- custody. The custody of children shall be assigned to Doña Candelaria. The main reason for this attribution is that it has been who has been exercising since the separation occurred.

3 .- USE AND ENJOY THE FAMILY HOME. The use and enjoyment of family housing, located in the C / DIRECCION000, NUM000 - NUM001 of (Madrid). be attributed to the Doña Candelaria and her two children. Also be attributed to Mr. Obdulio the use of ground located in CALLE000 NUM002 No, NUM003 Madrid, which, in addition to your home, the husband has set up his study of architecture.

4 .- visitation. To keep the visiting stated in the Order of Action, which is that, failing agreement, the parent can visit and have brought their young children alternate weekends, from Friday after school until 21 on Sunday, one afternoon a week, failing agreement will be on Wednesdays, from 17:00 am to 20:30 pm

With regard to school holidays, give the following visitation:

-Christmas holidays: the mother shall be with her children on Christmas Eve and Christmas Day and Father's day correspond Eve and New Year. Three Kings Day, in case of disagreement, will be shared by both parents, corresponding to the mother the night of Kings and the father may pick morning to spend the day with them.

-Summer Vacation: The vacation will be enjoyed by children half to each parent, in case of disagreement on the dates will go through each during even-numbered years the mother shall be first half of the holidays and the father over the years odd.

Holy Week will be enjoyed by even-numbered years the mother and the father in odd years.

As for the birthday child, the parent who does not have them with him on that date, you can visit and eat at the same company.

5 .- CONTRIBUTIONS TO THE FAMILY AND FOOD COSTS OF CHILDREN. Don Obdulio Doña Candelaria paid to the amount of € 2,200.00 per month (1,100 € for each of the children) by way of contribution to pay child maintenance and Beltran Mariana because this quantity that corresponds in proportion to their economic capacities.

Such amounts must be met also in monthly advance, within five days of each month and updated in accordance with the oscillations to experience the school that children attend.

6 .- expenses. As for the expenses of the children of the marriage, Mr. Obdulio pay 75% of them, and Dona Candelaria will face the remaining 25% payment in proportion to their income.

These costs include both medical, as their education and training professional or other nature that may be generated in the future. The realization of such expenses should always have the consent of both parents, and if no agreement be considered by the Court unless for reasons of urgency it is not possible to request such authorization.

7 .- USE AND USE OF VEHICLES. A Dona Candelaria's use and enjoyment of the Volkswagen Golf vehicle registration ....- N-NE, as well as Don Obdulio Volkswagen Passat vehicle registration ....- K-KR.

8 .- COMMON PROPERTY MANAGEMENT

1 .- The management of common property must be attributed to Dona Candelaria, it must observe the following rules of administration

1 .- Allocate income from housing rents Alcalá street and parking spaces Alcalá and Antonio Machado, as well as any other income that may arise from the Dower assets, payment of all loans, both mortgage and personal, of those who owes the conjugal partnership.

2 .- If these amounts are not sufficient to cover the cost of these goods, the difference will provide the spouses in half. If, however, after paying all expenses, remain a remnant, shall be apportioned between the spouses by 50%.

3 .- Each of the spouses will deal with both the cost of maintenance, communications, supplies, taxes (except those levied on property, etc.). the home in which they live and any other property which then has the use and enjoyment, including vehicles, of which each will meet the payment of road taxes that apply, and insurance, fines, etc. ..

Declared admissible the application was called the defendant, alleging a representation D. Obdulio the facts and legal arguments that apply to the case considered, finally asking: "... ruled on the agreed upon:

1 .- The dissolution by divorce of the marriage of Don and Doña Candelaria Obdulio and recording in the Civil Registry.

2 .- custody of minor children must be shared by both parents.

To grant permission to Mr. Obdulio to enroll the two children in the German School of Madrid.

3 .- To assign the custody of minor children in favor of Ms. Candelaria .

4 .- Establish a system of visits, placements and communications on behalf of Mr. Obdulio consisting of:

- Alternate weekends from Friday after school until Monday morning when the father left in the school.

- On the afternoon of Monday and Wednesday from after school until 20:00, when the refund at home mother.

- On the morning of Thursday, Mr. Obdulio may bring their children to school, picking them up at home mother and leaving them at school.

- Half of the school holiday periods of Christmas, Easter and summer. Even-numbered years will be the parent with the children who pass the first half of this period and in odd years happen to them the second half.

5 .- concept maintenance for two children, Mr. Obdulio must pay € 770 € -335 for each of them.

This amount shall be paid in monthly installments in advance and within the first five days of each month and will be updated annually on the basis of fluctuations experience the Consumer Price Index published by the Institute National Statistics or body that can replace him in that role. The first update will take place on January 1, 2006.

extraordinary medical expenses incurred to the health of the children shall be paid equally by the parents, being necessary prerequisite acceptance in the concept.

6 .- The use of family home and furnishings will be given to minor children and Ms. Candelaria.

7 .- The housing management of community property must be attributed jointly to both spouses. "

Set
also the Public Prosecutor by the same reply to the lawsuit alleging the facts and legal arguments which considered the application and ended up pleading, "... sentencing as to what is tested and based on the precepts invoked."

answer the complaint and given the appropriate moves, it was agreed to invite the parties to hold the appropriate View which took place on the day and hour and with the assistance of the parties having requested the receipt of litigation test, which proposal was carried by the parties, was declared relevant and with the result that work on cars.

The Court of First Instance No. 25, issued Judgement, dated November 25, 2005 and the following part: "FAILURE: Estimating partially suit filed by the Solicitor of the Courts Ms. MARIA DEL CARMEN ORTIZ Cornago on behalf of Ms. Candelaria against D. Obdulio, I decree the dissolution of marriage by divorce of Mr and Mrs Obdulio Candelaria, with the following statements:

- must ratify the measures agreed in the interim order issued by this Court dated January 11, 2005, While on visitation demos noted the following:

- As visitation will be both parents agree freely, taking into account the benefit and interest of minors and failing only will be as follows: Alternate weekends from Friday after school until 21 pm Sunday, two afternoons a week, which failing agreement between the parents will be: Monday afternoon and Wednesday from after school until 20 hours, half of Christmas vacation, Easter and summer, if discrepancy choosing even-numbered years the mother and odd-numbered years the father.

- No order for costs expressed.

SECOND. Against that Judgement appealed D. Obdulio. Substances On appeal, the Section 24 meetings of the Provincial Court of Madrid, issued a Judgement, dated November 10, 2006, with the following ruling: "It partially upheld the appeal filed by Mr. Obdulio, represented by Counsel MARÍA ALBARRACIN PASCUAL, against the decision dated November 25, 2005, the Court of First Instance No. 25 in Madrid, handed down in the process of divorce number 269/05, followed with Ms, Candelaria, represented by Counsel Ms M ª CARMEN ORTIZ Cornago, we REPEAL AND REPEALS resolution expressed the sense of pointing out the amount of child maintenance by the father of € 600 monthly per child, totaling € 1,200 per month, confirming the rest of the pronouncements of the decision under appeal, and no need to make delivery of an order for costs in this appeal to neither party.
THIRD
. Advertised special appeal for Infringement Litigation and appeal as Ms. Candelaria, against the appeal decision, the trial court had them for preparations and the party, represented by Counsel Ms Maria del Carmen Ortiz Cornago, the filed as follows :

appeal:

Unique .- Under the arts. 477.1 and 479.4 LEC, for violation of the rules to resolve the issues of process, being the same, first, arts. CC 145 and 146 relating to the maintenance responsibility and its quantification, and secondly, in so far as the question under discussion is specifically designed to set child support for minor, also cited Art. 39 of the English Constitution, the Declaration on the Rights of the Child proclaimed by the United Nations General Assembly 20/11/1989 ratified by Spain and the Organic Law 1 / 96 of January 15 for the Legal Protection of Minors.

extraordinary appeal Infringement Litigation:

Single
.- Under Art. 469.1,3 º LEC, for infringement of art. LEC 286.

By Order dated January 16, 2007, the Provincial Court agreed to the transfer of the original proceedings of the First Chamber of the Supreme Court.

FOUR. Received the file and made this roll, also joined the Attorney María del Carmen Ortiz Cornago, on behalf of Ms. Candelaria, and Attorney Albarracín María Pascual, on behalf of D. Obdulio, as defendant.

Allowed the appeals and procedural violation and evacuated the transfer conferred on the matter, the prosecutor, submitted a brief requesting the Special admissible Infringement Litigation, and contesting the appeal.

The Attorney Albarracín María Pascual, on behalf of D. Obdulio, challenged them, asking for a declaration does not call for resources.

FIVE. It was noted as a day for voting and decision of the appeal on the ninth of June two thousand ten, where the event took place.

has been Reporter Judge Hon. Mrs D ª. Encarnacion Roca Trias,

LEGAL

FIRST. The proven facts are:

1 º D ª Candelaria filed for divorce from her husband D. Obdulio. In relation to what is the subject of the appeal, the wife asked to remember the amount of 2,000 € per month (1,100 € for each child) to be paid by the husband as a contribution to household expenses and food for the children, be the appropriate amount to the respective economic capacities and needs of children.

2 In reply demand, the husband requested that the concept of alimony is agreed payment of € 770, ie € 335 for each child, and it was agreed that the payment of extraordinary medical expenses should be paid for the previous half agreement of both parents.

3 The Case of 1st Instance Court of Madrid n º 25, November 25, 2005, partially upheld the complaint. After ordering the dissolution of marriage by divorce, with regard to food of the children endorsed the provisional measures in the order of the court and to January 11, 2005.

4 º appealed D. Obdulio . The sentence of the AP in Madrid, section 24 of November 10, 2006, upheld the appeal in relation to the amount owed for food. He said that in accordance with applicable laws, ie the arts. 142, 144, 146 and 147 CC, "[...] the amount of food should be proportionate to the wealth and means of who gives and needs of the recipient "which is not a legal problem, but only "a factual question of determining a real effective and proportionate to the media that one and the other's needs", b) should reduce the amount of maintenance to € 600 per month per child, c) reason lies in the revenue perceived by the father, according to the record, and those perceived by their mothers work, which should also contribute to the maintenance owed to the children.

5 º D ª Candelaria has special appeal for procedural infringements, pursuant to art. 469, 1, 3 LEC, with only one reason, and appeal under art. 477, 2.3 LEC, also with a single reason. Both petitions were granted by order of this Court of January 27, 2009.

A) SPECIAL REMEDY FOR BREACH OF PROCESS.

SECOND. The only reason condemns the violation of art. 286 LEC, pursuant to art. 469, 1, 3 LEC. The appellant raises what are the consequences of not giving the procedure provided in art. 286 LEC when you have received the news of a new fact, happened once precluded the processing of claims. On June 6, 2006 was presented to the court a letter in which the appellant stated that on the same day he had learned that Mr. Obdulio had delivered on 15 May a work in the municipality of Marchamalo, budgeted at 1276787, € 41, that the wife had met appellant on appeal after the processing of claims and through an Internet news. This was important for the realization of the perception by the respondent father revenues other than those that recognized, which would allow consideration of their professional income as liberal, who had denied throughout the proceedings and had failed to be tested. The Court did not move to the opposite side of the new facts alleged and issued an order on June 14, 2006 stating "there is no place to receive the test in this case to appeal or take into consideration the new facts alleged, not be applicable the case the provisions of art. 460 LEC and not to undermine that appeal. " The importance that this fact is based on the judgment food are set according to economic capacity of parents and not to enter this new fact, maintenance is reduced.

The reason is estimated.

says the recent decision of this Chamber, 9 February 2010 that "may be admitted that the claim procedure, preserving its existence, undergoes a certain development in the course of the process, the product of what is metaphorically called biology The claim procedure. But the possibility of taking into account events subsequent to the filing of the demand is only possible when they have a complementary or interpretation. In this condition must be understood subject the application of art. 426.4 LEC ", which states that" [ if] after the claim or defense something goes relevant fact to substantiate the claims of the parties to the litigation, or had come to the notice of the parties before any of these features may rely on the audience. "Ultimately, that decision states that prevails" [the] inability to alter the object of the process established in the application (art. 412.2 LEC), ie the basic facts comprising the claim, but that does not mean to be taken into account when they have that as a complement to the same sentence is concerned. A the preceding arguments should be added that the Civil Procedure Act relaxes proof in proceedings on ability, parentage, marriage and children in art. 752.1,1 LEC , Which states that "[...] these processes are decided in accordance with the facts that have been discussed and proven results, regardless of when they have been alleged or otherwise introduced into the procedure. "

The applicant had insisted throughout the proceedings in the possibility that the husband exercise his profession as an architect regardless of the employment relationship tested. Constitutes a new discovery of a document that could establish this fact and at least should have been reviewed by the Court. This is important for purposes of determining the amount of food to children. Therefore, taking into account that the introduction of the new fact does not alter the request in litigation to claim leadership, and should not be considered as a mutatio libelli, but has the characteristic complement referred to the decision of 9 February 2010, in interpretation of Article 286 LEC, allegedly infringed must be concluded that there has been a cause of nullity. The sentencing Chamber should have accepted this document for the purpose of studying the influence they may have or not effective in determining the amount due for food. By not doing so, a procedural violation has occurred prior to sentencing, which leads to the nullity having been left out this new fact.

B) appeal.

THREE. Estimated to have an extraordinary remedy for a breach of procedure, no need to go to consider the appeal.

FOUR. In accordance with the provisions of Article 476, 2, 4, LEC, to regulate the effects of the admission of the extra resources for infringement proceedings, "the Board void the ruling and ordered to replenish the state actions and time who had committed the offense or violation. "

therefore annulled the contested decision and actions to restore immediately prior to sentencing so that it re-issued as the Board of Appeal, pursuant to consider proven facts, determine the amount for food from children.

FIVE. The costs incurred by the appeal and the extraordinary remedy of infringement proceedings should not be imposed especially any of the parties (art. 398.2 LEC).

SIX. The end result of the two appeals determined not to take a position on the costs of the proceedings, which are at the expense of what you decide to appeal the new sentence.

the foregoing, on behalf of King and the authority of the English people.

BUGS

1 Estimating the extraordinary remedy of infringement proceedings brought by the legal representation of Candelaria against the decision of the Audiencia Provincial de Madrid, section 24 of November 10, 2006.

2 º aside the decision under appeal and restore the proceedings on appeal at the time did not allow the test of the new fact occurred, prior to sentencing, to re-sentencing with this in mind the purpose of determine the amounts due in respect of food. Annulment also affects the statement of the costs generated.

3 º Do not impose any particular parts of the costs incurred by the special appeals and infringement proceedings.

Rid
the Court referred to the relevant certification, to return the car and roll appeal is addressed.

Thus by this our sentence, to be inserted in the Collection of Laws copies passing the necessary effect, we pronounce it, sign and send Francisco Marin Castan .- .- .- Jose Antonio Seijas Quintana Trias .- Roca Rafael Encarnacion Gimeno-Bayon Cobos .- Signed and initialed.

PUBLICATION .- Read and was published earlier ruling by the Hon. MRS. D ª. Encarnacion Roca Trias, Rapporteur has been in the process of the present case, being held Public Hearing the First Chamber of the Supreme Court, today, of which as Secretary thereof, certify.