Thursday, October 18, 2007

Ap Biology Lab 5 Conclusion Ap Biology Lab 5?

Tenancies Tenancies - IBI Calculation

Date: November 7, 2008
Body:
Supreme Court Room: Civil I, Section 1


Viewed by First Chamber of the Supreme Court, composed of Judges set aside, the appeal against the ruling by the Audiencia Provincial de Alicante, Section Five, as a result of cars, number 128/02 oral proceedings, proceedings before the Trial Benidorm Instance number 8 on eviction and claim amount, which was brought by Mrs. Celestina, represented by the Solicitor of the Courts Ms. Irene Martinez Lopez, which is under appeal Doña Marina represented by Attorney Don José Luis Ferrer Recuero.

FACTUAL BACKGROUND

FIRST. Before the Court of First Instance number 8 Benidorm, were seen in the file, view eviction and claim amount, promoted at the request of Doña Celestina, to Doña Marina.

For the plaintiffs claim was made under the statutory requirements, which requested prior allegation of the facts and legal grounds: "... issue in their day sentence for declaring the contract avoided in lease for nonpayment income and similar amounts and order the defendant to pay Real Estate Tax Rate and refuse collection due for periods totaling of 883.98, plus legal interest of this sum, and the payment of all costs that are caused in this lawsuit. "

Declared admissible claim, the defendant replied stating as facts and the legal basis as appropriate, and ended up pleading to the court: "... in the decision handed agreed partially upheld the complaint, ordering the defendant to pay the amount of 883.98, which have already been paid, the action being dismissed resolution lease for non-payment, which must be acquitted the defendant, each party must pay the costs of your instance and shared by half, to be a partial estimate demand. "

By
Court ruling was issued on 22 June 2002, part of which is as follows:" FAULT: That full estimating the application filed by Mr Cabanes Marhuenda Attorney, on behalf and representation of Doña Celestina against Doña Marina, I declare and declare the lease, with reference to housing located in Benidorm, C / DIRECCION000 No NUM000, NUM001 NUM002 (formerly No NUM001, NUM003 NUM002), binds to both parties , and therefore, I condemn and condemn the defendant to vacate within the legal time, allow free and open to the plaintiff that dwelling on pain that, if not done, there will be launch and its costs.

Also, I must condemn and condemn Dona Marina to pay the plaintiff the amount of EIGHT HUNDRED EIGHTY-THREE EUROS AND NINETY-EIGHT CENTS (883.98), expressly imposing interest and costs incurred in this procedure the defendant ".

SECOND. A petition was filed an appeal which was accepted, and pursued it, the Audiencia Provincial de Alicante, Section Five, issued a decision dated February 6, 2003, as part is as follows: "Fault: With partial estimate of the appeal deducted against the ruling of the Court of First Instance No. 8 Benidorm dated June 22, 2002 in the proceedings emanating this roll, we reverse and reverse in part the resolution, and absolve Dona Marina in demand on resolution lease that brought Doña Celestina. That decision is confirmed as regards the order to pay 883.98 euros. Rejecting the challenge articulated by that applicant. No special statement on costs in both instances. ".

THREE. The Attorney Dona Irene López Martínez, representing Doña Celestina, formalized appeal that based on the following reasons:

Reason first. Contrary interpretation of the Board "a quo" to the mainstream legal doctrine sitting by numerous hearings regarding the qualification of Property Tax as the amount treated as income.

Reason
second. It is based on the basis of the violation committed by the trial court of the scientific doctrine and jurisprudence issued by other hearings on the concept of rate of Garbage as an amount treated as income to the effect that its failure to rise to full resolution the contract.

FOUR. Evacuated transfer conferred Attorney Don José Luis Ferrer Recupero, representing Doña Marina, lodged a challenge to the use and terms pleading with this court: "... sentencing deciding his dismissal, with costs against the appellant."

FIVE. By Order of this Court dated October 30, 2007 is agreed the acceptance of this resource.

SIX. Has not been applied by all parties holding a public hearing, noted for voting and ruling on October 30, 2008, which has taken place.

has been Reporter Judge Hon. D. CLEMENTE AUGER LIÑÁN

LEGAL

I.-The dispute which gave rise to this appeal was initiated by the appellant here, Doña Celestina cumulative exercise resolution action lease contract and eviction for nonpayment of the last five installments of IBI and garbage rates and claim amounts owed by such concepts. The procedure is directed against Doña Marina, verbal contract leasing the property from 1974 situated in the Calle DIRECCION000 NUM000 number, NUM001 NUM002 (before NUM001 number, NUM003 NUM002 ) In the town of Benidorm.

The expected court ruling declaring a demand full eviction and payment of amounts due, and although not considered non-payment of IBI as the amount treated as income for purposes of cause for termination of contract However, it does consider the failure to pay garbage fees supporting this cause resolution to fit it within the concept of providing the former LAU.

The sentence was appealed by both sides, making the appellant here, despite the full estimation of demand, against the legal argument not to consider the IBI as the amount treated as income.

The Court of Appeal annulled the decision partially reverses the ruling on the eviction by failing to consider that non-payment of IBI and garbage rates to determine cause of eviction and maintains the order to pay of the amounts due.

The applicant lodged an appeal on the basis of paragraph 3 of Article 477.2 of the LEC as there is interest appellate review in the procedure by conflicting jurisprudence of provincial courts in relation to two issues: first, whether the default of IBI can determine cause resolution of the lease entered into under the LAU of 1,964. The second question, whether the default rate of litter can be considered as an amount treated as income as possible, event of default, determine the resolution of lease .

SECOND. For procedural reasons, be discussed first, the second ground of appeal. This reason is based on the basis of the violation committed by the trial court of the scientific doctrine and jurisprudence issued by other hearings on the concept of rate of waste as much income assimilated to the effect that its failure to rise to the decision and void the contract, in this regard I note that the legal issue is resolved by applying a jurisprudence that has taken in this case the Fifth Section of the Audiencia Provincial de Alicante ".

the development of this reason it appears the disagreement of the appellant with the basis of right fourth of the contested decision it believes the garbage rates are not treated as income amounts that can determine the event of default, the resolution of lease . The appellant considers that the entry into force of the Urban Leases Act of 1994 allows Second transitional provision, 10.5 pass on the costs of services and supplies and therefore, as the garbage fee passed on to the tenant an amount is treated as income amount can determine cause for termination in accordance with 114.1 of the LAU of 1,964.

However, the appellant has not properly established the existence of interest appellate argued, therefore, basing it in the second paragraph of number 3 in conjunction with ordinal 3 of number 1, both of Article 477 of the Act Civil Procedure for Provincial Hearing conflicting jurisprudence, as in the original preparation are mentioned only in a different sense of the sentence appeal, various Provincial Courts Judgments, without at least two sentences are the same Court and Section, and in the meaning of the sentence appeal, only the approach of the contested decision is followed by another statement of the same Court and Section that the contested decision date, with to be fulfilled and only part of the equation that this Board considers necessary to establish appellate interest for this cause (two sentences of the same audience or Section as opposed to two separate judgments in respect of the same audience or section). Furthermore, not all statements made remain the approach advocated by the appellant on this point because most of them refer to the concept of IBI income as an amount comparable to but not all relate to the rate comparable to waste as much income. This implies that, at this stage of the proceedings, the plea of \u200b\u200binadmissibility of Article 483.2.3 ° in relation to Article 477.2,3 and 3, both of the Civil Procedure Law, becoming a cause for dismissal, that the Board proceed already been followed in other similar cases of processed under the current resources of the new Civil Procedure Act (and, SSTS 18.04.2005, on an application 1547/2002, 17.07.2008, on an application 3308/2001, and 09.01.2008 in 2892 / 2002 resource).

Therefore, this plea must be rejected

THREE. In the first ground of appeal, the appellant alleges "contrary interpretation of the Board" a quo "of the mainstream legal doctrine sitting by numerous hearings regarding the qualification of Property Tax as the amount treated as income. Indeed, the ruling of the 5th Section of the Provincial Court of Alicante, in interpreting Article 114, section 1 of the LAU in 1964 regarding classification of the term "amounts treated as income" has broken numerous legal doctrine seated as is clear from their grounds and the contents of the appeal decision "

The appellant appealed of appeal under ordinal 3 of Article 477.2 of the Code of Civil Procedure justifying the issue of the existence of "interest appellate review" by conflicting jurisprudence of provincial courts in relation to the consideration of IBI as the amount treated as income for purposes of resolution of the lease. This interest has been justified appellate review under the terms required by this Court because it provides such judgments in favor of this view of the Audiencia Provincial de Santa Cruz de Tenerife, 22 May 1998, 15 April 2000 and 1 April 2000 and in opposed sense, maintaining the contrary view is put the sentence appeal, which in turn cited Case the same audience and section 21 October 1999, April 19, 2000, 22 March 2000 and 21 December 2001.

The reason has to be estimated.

This Court has had occasion to rule on the legal question raised by the appellant, through decision of the plenary of 12 January 2007 in the following sense: "Declaring jurisprudence that the failure of the tenant's tax Real Estate in housing leases in force at the time of entry into force of the new Urban Leases Act of November 24, 1994, must be regarded as cause for termination within the ª Article 114-1 of the revised Urban Leases Act of 1964. "The legal basis for this assertion is contained in the Third Legal Grounds of the resolution which states:" When the case 1 st Article 114 refers to similar amounts Income is alluding to those whose payment is to take the tenant by law, using an open formula must be supplemented with that at all times permitted by applicable law. If under the current text of 1964 were, in some cases, the corresponding differences in the cost of services and supplies and those resulting from the impact of the amount of work carried out by the landlord, now regard the text of the new law leads to the conclusion that the new tenant's obligation to pay the amount of IBI has to deserve equal consideration, so that its failure-as is the failure of a monetary obligation added essential to the payment of income-empowers the landlord to seek a termination of the contract. Otherwise would force the landlord to undertake an annual exercise action claim against the defaulting tenant of an annual obligation of which is to respond while the contract is in force, which involves regular basis the necessary assimilation of these effects the obligation also periodic payment of rent. Moreover, the interpretation of the rules according to its spirit and purpose (Article 3 of the Civil Code) also has to consider the case of Article 114-1 resolutory meetings of the Urban Leases Act of 1964 has to understand now, default by the lessee of the property tax, while such a rule tends to protect the landlord against the tenant defaults on obligations obligate conditions, such as this, and meaningless estimate that the obligation imposed on contracts housing lease entered into after the entry into force of the new Act Urban Lease 1994, with the effect of dissolving its non-compliance (Article 27.2 a), and extended such lessee's obligation also to previous contracts governed by the 1964 Act, operate for the first resolution-in terms of which the legislator less protective immunity, and not for the latter covered by a right of indefinite extension, in which the maximum protection afforded to the tenant must be matched by a strict compliance with its obligations. "

having been resolved question raised by the appellant as aforesaid, and being contrary to this doctrine, maintained by the ruling under appeal, there has been a breach of Article 114.1 of the Consolidated ª the Tenancies Act approved by Decree n º 4.104/1964 of 24 December to consider the IBI no unpaid by the lessee as cause for termination of lease agreement between the parties.

In accordance with Article 487.2 LEC, having been an infringement of the rules applicable to resolve the issue in the process of the interpretation given to it by this Court, must marry the contested decision, it is the duty of this Court, by the positive effect on the jurisdiction, take the instance, and having considered accredited by the Provincial Court, according to the evidence examined, the non-payment of property tax receipts the years 1997, 1998, 1999, 2000 and 2001, this statement has not been distorted in this office and that is the factual basis Case, unchanged on appeal, should the partial annulment of the contested decision, declaring the contract void and of housing lease located in NUM000 Goldfinch Street, NUM001 NUM002 (before NUM003 NUM002 NUM001 number) in the town of Benidorm between Doña Marina and Doña Celestina debiéndose condemn Ms. Marina to vacate the dwelling on legal term under penalty of release, confirming the other pronouncements of the contested decision, in terms of ordering payment of 838.98 euros for non-payment of IBI and garbage rates from 1,997 to 2,001 years.

FOUR. In accordance with Article 398.2 of the Code of Civil Procedure is not appropriate for costs of this action, imposing the costs at first instance under Article 394 of the same body of law to the party that has been rejected all his claims, that is, to this appeal and defendant in the main action, while maintaining the delivery of the no order for costs of the appeal under article 398.2 of the LEC.

the foregoing, on behalf of King and the authority of the English people

BUGS

We should declare and declare HAVE PLACE IN PART to the appeal made by Doña Celestina, represented by Prosecutor of the Tribunals Doña María José Millán Valero against the ruling on appeal on 6 February 2003 by the Audiencia Provincial de Alicante, Section Five in the roll number 33/2003, and in virtue:

1 º. Declared jurisprudence of this Division assimilation income urban rental agreement amounts due IBI for unpaid

2 .- The house partially judgment, keeping the ruling on the defendant's conviction Ms Marina to pay the amount of 883.98 for non-payment of property tax and garbage fees the years from 1997 to 2001.

3 .- Assuming the roles of body solves the lease for the apartment located in the street DIRECCION000 NUM000, NUM001 NUM002 (before NUM003 NUM002 NUM001 number) in the town of Benidorm between Marina and Queen Doña Celestina Ms Marina condemning to vacate the dwelling on legal term under penalty of release.

4 .- It impose the costs at first instance the defendant without a specific statement of those incurred in the appeal.

5 .- There is no express declaration of payment of costs incurred in this appeal.

Rid
the Court referred to the relevant certificate to back the cars and Roll Hall
sent

Thus by this our sentence, to be inserted in the Collection of Laws copies passing the necessary effect, we pronounced , sign and send Xiol Juan Antonio Rios. Jesus Corbal Fernández.Clemente Liñán.Rubricado Auger.

PUBLICATION .- Read and was published earlier ruling by the Hon. SR. D. Clemente Auger Linan, Rapporteur has been in the process of the present case, being held Public Hearing the First Chamber of the Supreme Court, today, of which as Secretary thereof, certify.

0 comments:

Post a Comment